SpeakCAD vs STLsmith: two text-to-STL tools for functional parts
STLsmith and SpeakCAD aim at the same person: someone who needs a functional printed part and does not want to learn CAD. Both take a description with dimensions, apply printing rules and give you a file. STLsmith keeps it minimal: describe, refine, download an STL, paid with a one-time pack. SpeakCAD is a fuller editor: it works as well on a phone, edits parts you upload, exports 3MF and slices G-code for your printer.| Criterion | SpeakCAD | STLsmith |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | People with a 3D printer, no CAD skills assumed | The same: functional parts without CAD |
| Where it runs | Browser on any phone, tablet or computer; nothing to install | Browser (check their site for use on a phone) |
| Inputs | Starters (box, plate, cylinder, tray) and hand tools on a tapped face; text, photos with a ruler to copy a part, STL/3MF/.scad uploads | Text, in English or Spanish |
| Editing | Tap a face: hole, cut, add, extrude, text, rounded corners, filleted or chamfered edges, a shell, copies in a row, a grid or a circle, measure, in millimetres you type, free; or chat: say what to change, the rest stays | Refine by chat (“5mm thicker”) |
| Printability | Wall thickness, clearances, flat base and overhang rules applied by default | FDM rules: 2 mm minimum walls, M3–M5 screw clearances, parts flat on the bed |
| Scope | Functional parts from hooks to multi-part enclosures; edits of uploaded STL/3MF; copies from photos | Hooks, brackets, spacers, boxes, knobs, mounts; no figurines |
| Output | STL, 3MF, G-code sliced for your printer | STL |
| Sliced G-code | Yes, for 380+ printers, at the price of the STL | No: open the STL in your slicer |
| Test the fit before a long print | Fit Check: free 5-minute test slice of the fit, then your printer's calibration is applied to every model | No: reprint, or cut a test piece yourself |
| Free to try | Hand tools (hole and screw head, cut, add, extrude, text, rounded corners, filleted or chamfered edges, shell, copies, measure) and the STL or 3MF they make, with a free account; live demo (3 AI edits of a real part, no account); 650+ ready-made library models open in a free account and resize in the viewer; AI requests use credits, downloads (G-code too) are included in every plan | No free generation: a sample part (an M5 spacer) to inspect, no account needed |
| Price | Maker $7.99/mo (50 credits); Pro $14.99/mo; Unlimited $79.99/mo | $9 once for 100 AI generations or refinements; credits never expire; no subscription (check their site) |
Same promise
Both tools start from the same observation: generative mesh models are wrong for parts that have to fit, and most people who need a bracket will never learn CAD. So both take a plain description with real numbers, apply FDM rules (walls, screw clearances, a flat base) and return a file that prints.
Where STLsmith wins
- Price per part. $9 once for 100 generations or refinements, with credits that never expire, is cheaper per part than SpeakCAD's credits (check their site for current prices).
- No subscription. You pay once and keep the credits.
- Simplicity. One box, one file.
STLsmith no longer gives free generations: its free option is a sample part to inspect. SpeakCAD's free options are the hand tools and the files they make, the live demo on a sample part, and the 650+ ready-made library models to resize; describing your own part to the AI uses credits.
Where SpeakCAD wins
- The phone. SpeakCAD's editor is built for a phone first.
- More than STL. 3MF and G-code sliced with official profiles for 380+ printers.
- Starting from an existing file. Upload an STL or 3MF and change it, or copy a part from two photos and a ruler.
- Bigger parts. Enclosures with lids, multi-part layouts, threads and snap fits, with every dimension a named parameter you can change later.
- Fit Check, which calibrates clearances to your printer before a long print.
How the costs compare
STLsmith counts parts. SpeakCAD counts AI requests (4 credits for a new part on a plan, its first 3 small changes free, 3 for a design change, 2 for a small change, 1 for a quick edit such as a changed size); downloads are included in every plan (4 credits without one). A typical part with a small change and a few quick edits is about 6 credits, so Maker's 50 credits a month ($7.99) cover about 8 parts.